MCWC  The Mendocino Quill
  • The Quill
  • ABOUT
  • CONTACT | SUBMISSIONS
  • GET LINKED

Authenticity, the critics' new buzzword

3/1/2015

1 Comment

 

Ponderings by Henri Bensussen

MCWC board member,
Mendocino Quill's editor, a.k.a. The Maven
Picture
BLOG MAVEN Henri/etta Bensussen
Henri serves on the board of the Mendocino Coast Writers Conference. She worries endlessly, fruitlessly, and in between writes tragic poetry and comical short stories.


Email Henri
as The Maven
“The realist tradition makes . . . the doctrine of authenticity peddled by creative writing classes the world over all the more simple-minded,” writes Tom McCarthy (London Review of Books, 12/18/14), because, quoting Nietzsche, “truths” are so illusory that “one has forgotten that they are illusions.” … “The real, here,” he states, “is no longer anything like a fact or a secret … and has nothing to do with authenticity.”

Elaine Blair (New Yorker, 1/5/15) thinks modern authors are newly concerned about the “fakeness” of their creations, and are trying to overcome this by “incorporating the techniques of memoir and essay of effacing the difference between fiction and their own personal nonfictions,” to make them authentic.

According to Webster’s, the word authenticity means: “Authoritative,” i.e., “official; entitled to credit or acceptance. Worthy of acceptance or belief as conforming to fact or reality (the authentic story); not imaginary, false, or imitation.” 

How does a scene in a story become “worthy of acceptance,” the Maven wonders—if  it sounds real, does that make it real? Or do readers expect the novels they read to be based on some true event, and thus are disappointed when they find out the experiences have been re-fashioned by art into just another entertaining story? Is that why book titles so often end with the words “A Novel,” to fend off suspicion that the book could be based on true events, and so avoid any need to apologize for not sticking to actual historical facts? 

Dramatic writing implies the ability to stand back and observe, to re-fashion an event by imagining a different response than what “really” happened, or to explore and enhance its emotional and sensory context. If the result is “authentic” to the situation, it’s more likely to be the kind of literature readers enjoy. 

“Write it real,” William Carlos Williams said. As in science fiction or fantasy, the place or time may not be “real,” and the action may be imagined rather than factual, but the total experience of the story, though stretched like pizza dough, stays “true” to the author’s intention in ways we think of as possible. 

Memoir can feed the novel, and dramatic prose can feed memoir to invest it with a hyper-reality. Even the surreal should have the stamp of authentic experience, which, to the Maven, is her usual reality.


TO COMMENT, click on "Comments" above or below the post, then fill in the form, or click on "Reply" of another comment to add to that comment. 

SHARE on your Facebook or Twitter, hit the buttons:
1 Comment
norma watkins link
3/2/2015 08:42:21 am

My head is spinning.
Is it real?

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    CONFERENCE WEBSITE:
    www.MCWC.org
    Blog Posts Via E-Mail

    RSS Feed

    (RSS Feed) Chrome users who see code: get Google RSS extension
    Submission Guidelines

    Tags

    All
    Amie McGee
    Art Car
    Believe In Yourself
    Blake More
    Chapbooks
    Diverse Books
    Ellen Bass
    Essay
    Evoke Memory
    Evoking The Muse
    Find Prompts
    Find Publisher
    Find Time To Write
    Flockworks
    Frame
    Hether Ludwig
    Indigo Moor
    Influence Of TV
    Interviews
    James W. Hall
    Janet Self
    Jasper Henderson
    Jessica Kotnour
    Karen Lewis
    Kate Erickson
    Kat Meads
    Kenyon College
    Kim Addonizio
    Laura Atkins
    Les Standiford
    Malcolm Margolin
    Marcela Griffin
    Marketing
    Mary Karr
    Maureen Eppstein
    Meet Agent
    Memoir
    MFA
    Molly Dwyer
    Montage
    Motivations
    NaNoWriMo
    Nicole Idar
    Nona Smith
    Norma Watkins
    Noyo River Review
    Passionate Writers
    Peter Orner
    Poetry
    Poetry And Photography
    Poetry Manuscript
    Poets & Writers
    Printing Press
    Print Power
    Promotion
    Publishers Marketplace
    Reyna Grande
    Romance Novels
    Scene
    Scott Hutchins
    Self Publishing
    SFSU
    Sharon Dubiago
    Teen Experience
    Titles
    Tragic Poetry
    Traveling Sprinkler
    Why I Write
    Writers Conference
    Writers Groups
    Writing Contest
    Writing Critique
    Writing Discipline
    Writing Goals
    Writing Time
    Young Adult

Proudly powered by Weebly